Before We Were Yours by Lisa Wingate review

Before We Were Yours by Lisa Wingate: A Thought-Provoking Journey of Historical Fiction

Before We Were Yours, written by Lisa Wingate and published in 2017, is a haunting and poignant historical fiction novel that explores the harrowing realities of family, adoption, and the dark secrets hidden within the corridors of time. This captivating novel skillfully weaves together a tale of lost children, family ties, and the lasting impacts of historical injustices. Wingate takes readers on a thought-provoking journey, asking important moral questions that resonate deeply with anyone interested in human history, identity, and the power of love and resilience.

Plot Overview:

Before We Were Yours alternates between two timelines: one set in the 1930s and one in the present day. The novel is based on the real-life events surrounding the notorious Tennessee Children's Home Society, a covert adoption agency run by the ruthless Georgia Tann, responsible for kidnapping and selling children to wealthy families. In the past, the story follows Rill Foss, a young girl who, along with her siblings, is stolen from their home and placed in this horrific system. In the present day, Avery Stafford, a successful attorney and the granddaughter of a prominent South Carolina family, is drawn into a mystery that begins to unravel her own family’s connection to the adoption scandal.

As Avery uncovers her family's hidden past, the novel explores the deep emotional toll that these stolen lives have taken and the courage it takes to confront history's darkest secrets. The primary conflict centers around Avery’s search for truth and Rill’s fight for survival in an unjust system. Through both timelines, the novel delves into the emotional and physical scars left on those whose lives were forever altered by Georgia Tann’s actions.

Themes and Key Messages:

One of the central themes of Before We Were Yours is the concept of family—what it means to belong, and the lengths one will go to protect loved ones. The novel also addresses the moral complexities surrounding adoption, identity, and the deep emotional trauma that comes with being separated from one’s biological family.

Wingate shines a light on the corrupt practices of the Tennessee Children’s Home Society and the way society has historically treated those without power, especially children. Through the characters’ experiences, Wingate raises significant moral questions: Can one truly forget their origins? What does it mean to be “home”? How do we reconcile with past wrongs, especially when the consequences still affect future generations?

Character Development:

The novel features deeply developed characters, particularly Rill Foss, whose strength and vulnerability make her a memorable protagonist. Rill’s emotional arc as she endures unimaginable hardship and struggles to hold onto hope is compelling and heartfelt. Avery Stafford’s character arc is equally engaging; her journey from skepticism to understanding and empathy is a testament to the healing power of truth.

Both Rill and Avery’s characters feel incredibly real and relatable, with their internal struggles and emotional growth resonating with readers. The impact of family secrets and the power of personal discovery are at the heart of their development, making their stories unforgettable.

Writing Style and Pacing:

Lisa Wingate’s writing style is eloquent and accessible, making Before We Were Yours a fluid and engaging read. Her descriptive prose brings both the past and the present to life with vivid detail, immersing the reader in the emotional landscape of the characters. The pacing of the novel is well-balanced—while the present-day storyline moves forward quickly with suspense and mystery, the historical timeline provides rich backstory that deepens the emotional stakes without slowing the overall momentum.

Wingate does a remarkable job of keeping readers engaged by shifting between timelines and unveiling new information at just the right moments. The balance between plot progression and character depth makes the book difficult to put down.

Impact on the Reader:

Before We Were Yours is an emotional rollercoaster, evoking feelings of sadness, anger, and ultimately, hope. The book makes you reflect on the nature of family, the power of resilience, and the importance of confronting uncomfortable truths. Readers may find themselves questioning the choices made by those involved in historical injustices, but they will also be inspired by the strength of those who fought to reclaim their dignity and identity.

This novel challenges perspectives, particularly around the topic of adoption and the concept of "home," while also offering a reminder of the importance of family history and legacy.

Conclusion:

In conclusion, Before We Were Yours by Lisa Wingate is a remarkable work of historical fiction that explores themes of family, love, loss, and the power of truth. The novel is an emotional journey that will stay with you long after the last page is turned. I highly recommend it to anyone who enjoys historical fiction, family sagas, or books that provoke deep moral reflection.

If you are a fan of powerful, heart-wrenching stories that combine suspense with emotional depth, this book is a must-read. Whether you're interested in adoption stories, family drama, or historical mysteries, Before We Were Yours will appeal to a wide range of readers. Its impact is lasting, and it is sure to evoke deep emotions and thought-provoking discussions for book clubs and readers alike.